If a school identifies 15 percent of black students as having disabilities, but only 5 percent of white students, is that a problem?
What if the black students with disabilities are disciplined more frequently or with tougher consequences?
This is known in special education as significant disproportionality. Lindsay Jones, chief policy and advocacy officer for the National Center for Learning Disabilities (NCLD), says it is indeed a problem. Here, she answers common questions parents may have.
Q: What is significant disproportionality?
A: Significant disproportionality is when a school district identifies students from any racial or ethnic group for special education at markedly higher rates than other students. This is a concern not because students are being identified as having disabilities, but because they may be identified as having disabilities when they don’t actually have one.
And it’s not just about identification for services. In fact, there’s a provision in special education law that requires school districts to figure out if students in these groups are treated differently. To do so, they must consider three key questions:
- Are certain groups of students identified for special education or identified with particular types of disabilities at different rates?
- Are kids of different racial groups placed in more restrictive class settings, like separate classrooms or schools, at different rates than others?
- Are students of different racial and ethnic groups disciplined more often and/or more harshly than others?
If the answer to any of those questions is “yes,” districts are required by IDEA to figure out the cause of the disparity and address the issue.
Q: Why is it a problem?
A: These disparities can have a negative impact on students for many reasons. For instance, students who are misidentified may not be getting the right supports to succeed in school.
Consider these points:
- Research shows that minority students and English language learners are not only disproportionately labeled as needing special education services,they are also more likely to be placed in more restrictive settings.
- During the 2013–2014 school year, black students made up nearly 16 percent of students in public schools, but they made up 20 percent of students identified with a specific learning disability (SLD) that year.
- That same year, Asian students made up nearly 5 percent of public school students, but they made up only 1.5 percent of students with SLD.
- 1 in 4 black boys identified with disabilities are suspended each year, while only 1 in 10 white boys identified with disabilities are suspended.
Research shows that inclusion in general education classrooms (as opposed to restrictive settings) can improve academic and social outcomes for students with disabilities—particularly for students with learning disabilities. And kids who are suspended miss out on important instruction. That can lead to lower levels of educational success.
Q: How has the federal government approached the issue?
A: While IDEA requires states to address this issue in their districts, a 2013 government study showed that many states were not doing it well. They were not doing a good enough job of looking at their data and addressing issues. In fact, some states set up their systems in a way that they’d likely never identify any districts as having an issue.
The study recommended that the U.S. Department of Education develop a standard approach for states to review and address these disparities. To try to fix the problem, the federal government wrote regulations in 2016 known as the “Equity in IDEA” regulations. These are sometimes referred to as the “Significant Disproportionality” regulations or rules.
This created a way for all states to review their data and set up a fair system across the country. It also gave districts additional flexibility in how they can use IDEA funds to address problems.
The “Significant Disproportionality” regulations are set to take effect in July of 2018. However, the Trump administration has ordered a two year delay in implementation in order to do their own analysis of the problem and possibly develop a different approach.
Q: What can you do to learn more?
A: You can learn more about significant disproportionality from NCLD. If your child has an IEP or a 504 plan, read about rights around discipline. You can also watch a short video from the National Disability Rights Network about the proposed changes
Reprinted from Understood.org
